The four temperaments are an old way of sorting people into Sanguine, Choleric, Phlegmatic and Melancholic. The history of the four temperaments starts in ancient medicine, with a theory of bodily fluids that medicine dropped long ago. Psychology kept the four names, and today they work mostly as labels for the four quarters of a plane drawn by two continuous scales, extraversion and neuroticism.
Body fluids: Hippocrates and Galen
The four fluids first appear in On the Nature of Man, a treatise in the Hippocratic collection and the earliest known text with the scheme: blood, phlegm, yellow bile and black bile. Its authorship is disputed. Aristotle names Polybus, Hippocrates’s son-in-law and pupil; Galen, several centuries later, was sure it was Hippocrates himself. The physicians of that collection worked roughly between 450 and 350 BCE.
What the treatise says is about health. The body contains the four fluids, and it’s healthiest when they’re mixed in balanced proportion. Pain comes when one of them becomes too little, too much, or separates off and isn’t blended with the rest. A physician looked for the surplus or the shortage, and treated with opposites: a body overfull was emptied, a body drained was refilled, which is where bloodletting comes from.
There are no character types in it. The text sorts fluids, and its examples are about weather and illness: in spring, when the blood is warmest, dysentery and nosebleeds were expected, and people were advised to change their way of living with the season.
As the scheme came down to later writers, each fluid carried two qualities and a season. Blood was warm and moist (spring), yellow bile warm and dry (summer), black bile cold and dry (autumn), phlegm cold and moist (winter). The four names for kinds of people took shape later, in the Galenic tradition.
Galen was born in Pergamon in 129 CE and wrote On Temperaments, a large and very influential work on mixture. For him a body is a blend of elements, described by whichever qualities dominate. A well-balanced blend gives health; a badly balanced one causes disease. He described blends of the four qualities in many combinations, and the four names came from the tradition after him.
He also built a bridge from body to behavior: the mixture of the body affects the soul. Yellow bile was linked with sharpness and intelligence, black bile with persistence and consistency, and an excess of yellow bile was held to cause anger and unreasonable behavior. The names follow the fluids: Sanguine from blood, Choleric from yellow bile, Melancholic from black bile, Phlegmatic from phlegm.
Take a man who flares up at the smallest thing. A physician of this school wouldn’t ask what he’d been through. He’d look for too much yellow bile, which is warm and dry, and think of removing or countering the excess. Shakespeare could count on the audience knowing the scheme: in The Taming of the Shrew, Petruchio handles the choleric Katherina with cold, mutton and sleeplessness.
The physician Avicenna (980-1037) finished his Canon of Medicine in 1025, built on the four fluids and widened to include temperaments as combinations of hot, cold, moist and dry, tied to emotional, mental and moral traits. Insomnia, in his account, went with a dry and hot condition. Gerard of Cremona translated the Canon into Latin in the thirteenth century; universities taught from it from the fourteenth, and in Padua it was still read as a background text in 1715. Galen’s views dominated Western medicine for more than 1,300 years.
From medicine to character: Kant
In 1798 Kant published Anthropology from a Pragmatic Point of View, and one section of it is about temperament. He separates two meanings of the word. The physiological one concerns the body’s constitution, the fluids and how the life force moves them. The psychological one concerns the temperament of the soul, its way of feeling and wanting. Expressions taken from the doctrine of blood, he says, serve as an analogy for how feelings and desires play out, with blood possibly their bodily cause. From there Kant sorts people by what they do and leaves the bodily causes aside.
He uses two axes. One is feeling and the other is activity, and each pairs two temperaments: Sanguine and Melancholic belong to feeling, Choleric and Phlegmatic to activity. The Sanguine and the Melancholic differ in how an impression behaves. The Sanguine is quickly and strongly gripped, but the impression doesn’t go deep or last. The Melancholic looks less affected from outside, and the impression takes root. Kant says outright that the difference lies in how an impression behaves, so a cheerful Melancholic is possible.
His Sanguine is carefree and full of hope. He promises honestly and then doesn’t keep his word, because he never thought about whether he could. He’s generous and a poor debtor who keeps asking for extensions, pleasant company, a friend to everyone; remorse passes quickly, and he tires fast of work but never of play.
The Melancholic puts great weight on whatever touches him personally and sees reasons for worry everywhere. Where the Sanguine sees the chance of success first, he sees the difficulties first, so he thinks deeply where the Sanguine thinks on the surface. He rarely promises, because keeping his word matters to him and he doubts he can. Kant adds that this caution comes from his feelings, so it earns no moral credit.
The Choleric, for Kant, is hot and flares up like a fire of straw. His activity is quick and short, his anger carries no hatred and passes quickly if people give way. He likes to command and prefers that others do the work; ambition and public affairs are his passions, and he likes show. Kant calls this temperament the least happy, since it draws the most resistance.
The Phlegmatic has an absence of affect, and a man with a lot of phlegm shouldn’t be written off as an idler. As a weakness, he leans toward doing nothing. As a strength, he’s hard to move and slow to move, but once moving he goes on for a long time. He doesn’t get angry easily and first considers whether it’s worth it. His happy temperament, Kant writes, stands in for wisdom. In the family he rules by seeming to give in, and he’s called cunning because attacks bounce off him like off a sack of wool.
Kant gives each temperament a religious footnote: the Choleric is orthodox, the Sanguine a freethinker, the Melancholic a dreamy zealot, the Phlegmatic indifferent. And he rejects mixed temperaments. Opposites, Sanguine with Melancholic or Choleric with Phlegmatic, contradict each other. Neighbors neutralize each other, in something like a chemical mixture. So there are only four, each simple, and he says he doesn’t know what to do with a person who ascribes a mixed temperament to himself.
Pavlov: a nervous system instead of fluids
Physiologists took the next step. Ivan Pavlov won the Nobel Prize in 1904, and in the 1920s he set out a typology of nervous system properties, built on experiments with dogs that had begun earlier. He kept the Hippocratic names and gave an existing four-part classification a physiological explanation.
The experiments were on salivary conditioned reflexes. Dogs fell first into weak and strong, then into balanced and unbalanced, then into mobile and inert. Behind this are three properties. Strength is the ability of nerve cells to endure a strong stimulus without sliding into protective inhibition; in a weak system that inhibition comes quickly, even under a small load.
Mobility is the speed with which one process replaces another, and in the lab it showed in how fast a dog could be retrained when the signal was changed. Balance is the ratio of excitation to inhibition. Pavlov held that not every combination makes sense: balance isn’t worth assessing in a weak system, nor mobility in strong, unbalanced ones. That leaves four types.
The correspondence usually given runs like this. A strong, balanced, mobile system is Sanguine. Strong, balanced, inert is Phlegmatic. Strong and unbalanced, with excitation outrunning inhibition, is Choleric. A weak system is Melancholic. When experiments pushed dogs to a breakdown, it looked different by type: some went into uncontrolled excitement, others into complete inhibition.
For Pavlov, temperament was a genotype that environment turns into a phenotype, character. His method moved to people in the 1930s, and especially from the 1960s. His pupils, Kupalov and Ivanov-Smolensky among them, found many intermediate variants.
Eysenck: two scales and four quadrants
Hans Eysenck’s book Dimensions of Personality (1947) named extraversion and neuroticism as the two main dimensions. The term “neuroticism” is his. The axis grew out of a factor analysis of a medical questionnaire for soldiers, run in 1944; the fluids had no part in it. Extraversion has its own page on introversion and extraversion.
The four names fit onto the two scales as quadrants. High neuroticism and high extraversion is Choleric, high neuroticism and low extraversion is Melancholic, low neuroticism and high extraversion is Sanguine, low and low is Phlegmatic. In Eysenck’s own 1947 scheme the quadrants carry position labels, stable introvert and unstable extravert for example.
He later remarked that his two dimensions recall the four types Galen proposed, and he leaned on Pavlov’s excitation and inhibition as a physiological base. Explanations changed: in 1957 he linked neuroticism to Pavlov’s processes, in 1967 to activation of the limbic system, and he explained extraversion through cortical arousal. On that account the introvert, who is more aroused inside, looks for a quiet room, and the extravert, who needs more stimulation, looks for a noisy party. A review published in 2013 calls such explanations never quite satisfactory.
| Temperament | In Galen’s tradition | Pavlov’s nervous system | Eysenck’s quadrant |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sanguine | blood; warm and moist | strong, balanced, mobile | low neuroticism, high extraversion |
| Choleric | yellow bile; warm and dry | strong, unbalanced (excitation outweighs inhibition) | high neuroticism, high extraversion |
| Phlegmatic | phlegm; cold and moist | strong, balanced, inert | low neuroticism, low extraversion |
| Melancholic | black bile; cold and dry | weak | high neuroticism, low extraversion |
Kant isn’t in the table, because he sorted by feeling and activity.
Eysenck’s tests followed: the Eysenck Personality Inventory in 1964 and the Eysenck Personality Questionnaire in 1975, which added psychoticism as a third scale. All of them measure the scales.
Extraversion and neuroticism come close to the traits of the same names in the Big Five. Psychoticism lines up with low conscientiousness and low agreeableness, and openness has no counterpart in Eysenck’s model. In the Big Five every trait is a continuous scale, and the model treats extraversion as a continuum with most people a mixture.
The tests and the four types are collected on the temperaments system page.
What’s outdated and what’s left
The fluids lost their ground in stages. Vesalius revised Galen’s anatomy in 1543, and Harvey challenged theories of the blood in 1628. Humoral medicine held in Europe until the end of the seventeenth century, when the new science of Galileo, Descartes, Newton and Boyle, with its mechanics, chemistry and mathematics, pushed it aside. It lingered in the eighteenth century in bloodletting and purges.
In 1858 Rudolf Virchow gave twenty lectures in Berlin, published as Cellular Pathology: disease lives in the cell. That’s usually named as the decisive turn. Medicine refuted humoral theory as a medical doctrine, and traces of it remain in traditional Arabic medicine and Ayurveda.
The four names stayed, and what’s behind them changed. Kant insisted there are no mixtures. On Eysenck’s scales people stand at any point, and the names are only quarters of the plane. These are two models, and each answers in its own way. What authors write under each name varies a lot, and the results of experiments agree only in part, so comparing temperaments with other typologies has become unpopular, because the definitions are blurry.
Research on temperament in children went off in another direction: from the early 1950s the New York Longitudinal Study (Thomas, Chess and Birch, 1968) described easy, difficult and slow-to-warm-up babies.
A person near the middle of an axis is neither one nor the other. Say a test places someone just above the middle on extraversion and just below the middle on neuroticism: Sanguine. Two answers change on a retake, both scores shift a little, and the result reads Phlegmatic or Choleric. The name flipped because of the border, while the position on the axes barely moved.
A temperament questionnaire finds a person’s position on two scales. CoreTypes answers a different question. A scale tells you how much of a given trait a person has; CoreTypes looks for a type, meaning the way the mind processes information: what a person notices first and what they talk about easily and in detail. Here the type is identified from the meaning of speech, and the free CoreTypes test follows the same logic: 36 questions, four answers each (sets of words, ready-made phrases or a short scene), about ten minutes, no sign-up. The result is one of 16 types with a free type page. Take the CoreTypes test.
How to read a temperament test result
The position on the two axes tells more than the name. Two people can both get Sanguine. One stands at the far edge of extraversion with low neuroticism, the other just above the middle on extraversion and close to average on neuroticism. The name is shared and the position is not. The description of a lively, sociable, calm person fits the first better.
Temperament and character are separate things. For Pavlov, character is what environment makes of the inborn temperament. Kant, right after the section on temperament, takes up character as a way of thinking and treats it as something larger. Two people with Phlegmatic results can differ a good deal: one sits down to a task and finishes it, the other puts it off for weeks.
One more name to keep apart: the Keirsey temperaments, from 1978, are a different system tied to MBTI codes and have nothing to do with the classical four.
Anyone who wants to try it can take the temperament test and then read the system page. Retaking it in a different mood and comparing the positions on the two axes shows how far a result moves; the description of the neighboring quadrant is worth reading too.
Sources
- Immanuel Kant, "Anthropologie in pragmatischer Hinsicht" (Anthropology from a Pragmatic Point of View), 1798, Academy edition, vol. VII, pp. 285-291. korpora.org/Kant/aa07/285.html
- Galen, "Commentary on Hippocrates' On the Nature of Man", trans. W. J. Lewis and J. A. Beach, 1998. homepages.ucl.ac.uk/~ucgajpd/medicina%20antiqua/Medant/GNatHom1.htm
- "Galen", Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. plato.stanford.edu/entries/galen
- Alan Pickering, Andrew Cooper, Luke Smillie, Philip Corr, "On the shoulders of giants", The Psychologist, 2013. bps.org.uk/psychologist/shoulders-giants
- A. K. Drozdovsky, "The connection between typological complexes of properties of the nervous system, temperaments, and personality types in the professions and sports", Open Access Journal of Sports Medicine, 2015. dovepress.com/the-connection-between-typological-complexes-of-properties-of-the-nerv-peer-reviewed-fulltext-article-OAJSM
- "Humours", Encyclopedia.com. encyclopedia.com/medicine/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/humours